Listen, stop the scrub. That tight feeling means you stripped your skin barrier. When you strip the barrier, your skin panics and produces even MORE oil to compensate. That's why you're an oil slick. Here is the real routine for oily acne: 1. Gentle, non-foaming cleanser (look for ceramides or hyaluronic acid). 2. A salicylic acid toner (2% max) – this gets inside the pore. 3. An oil-free gel moisturizer. Yes, oily skin still needs moisturizer. If you skip it, you get rebound oil. 4. Sunscreen in the morning (zinc oxide is great because it dries out oil slightly). Do this for two weeks. Your oil production will drop by about 50%. For the blackheads, you need patience. Salicylic acid takes 6-8 weeks to dissolve the gunk inside the pore. Don't squeeze them – you'll scar.